The Anna Karenina Theory of the Unconscious Commentary
نویسنده
چکیده
The Anna Karenina theory says: all conscious states are alike; each unconscious state is unconscious in its own way. This paper argues that many components have to function properly to produce consciousness, but failure in any one of many different ones can yield an unconscious state in different ways. In that sense the Anna Karenina theory is true. But in another respect it is false: kinds of unconsciousness depend on kinds of consciousness.
منابع مشابه
The Anna Karenina Principle and Skepticism about Unconscious Perception
All conscious perceptions are alike but each unconscious perception is unconscious in its own way. This “Anna Karenina” (Tolstoy, 1901, first sentence) principle concerning unconscious perception (Block, 2011) holds because conscious perception is a matter of oscillating feed-forward and feed-back signals that are uniform in the essential features of their successes but variegated in their fail...
متن کاملThe Anna Karenina Bias : Which Variables to Observe ? Steven
T opening of Count Lev Nikolayevich (Leo) Tolstoy’s novel inspired linguist, molecular physiologist and biogeographer Jared M. Diamond’s eponym for the Anna Karenina principle (Diamond 1997). The principle suggests that no one property guarantees success but many guarantee failure. The Anna Karenina (TAK) bias is a logical consequence. TAK bias is more insidious than the kindred Survivor bias, ...
متن کاملThe Ghost Is the Machine: How Can We Visibilize the Unseen Norms and Power of Global Health?; Comment on “Navigating Between Stealth Advocacy and Unconscious Dogmatism: The Challenge of Researching the Norms, Politics and Power of Global Health”
In his recent commentary, Gorik Ooms argues that “denying that researchers, like all humans, have personal opinions … drives researchers’ personal opinion underground, turning global health science into unconscious dogmatism or stealth advocacy, avoiding the crucial debate about the politics and underlying normative premises of global health.” These ‘unconscious’ dimensions of global health are...
متن کاملGlobal Health Warning: Definitions Wield Power; Comment on “Navigating Between Stealth Advocacy and Unconscious Dogmatism: The Challenge of Researching the Norms, Politics and Power of Global Health”
Gorik Ooms recently made a strong case for considering the centrality of normative premises to analyzing and understanding the underappreciated importance of the nexus of politics, power and process in global health. This critical commentary raises serious questions for the practice and study of global health and global health governance. First and foremost, this commentary underlines the impor...
متن کاملTolstoy ’ s Professional Conscience : The Business Model in Anna Karenina
In Gallup’s 2013 State of the American Workplace Report,a staggering 70 percent of American workers expressed dissatisfaction with their jobs, which respondents’ primarily contributed to issues with poor managers who did not foster their talents, growth or creativity(Grant 1). This massive number of disgruntled employees has far reaching effects beyond the psychological wellbeing of individual ...
متن کامل